4. (Tied) Anthony Mason (2001)

Mason had a long 13-year career after initially getting his shot as a third-round draft pick in 1989. He was never a huge offensive threat, with a weird jump shot that was inconsistent, but he hustled on defense and grabbed boards.

Perhaps it was his hustle that won over the fans, who voted him onto the All-Star team. It also could’ve been his hairstyles, which were always unique. He averaged 15.5 PPG and 9.6 RPG heading into the break that year, while several other players with better stats didn’t get his spot.