3. Tyrone Hill (1995)

Cleveland’s Hill was a quality forward throughout his career, but he always left a lot to be desired in the stats department. Hill did average career highs in points and rebounds in his All-Star season, but 13.8 PPG and 10.9 RPG were nothing to write home about.

In fairness to Hill, this was definitely the best season of his career. However, there were several other players who deserved his spot. The coaches still voted him onto the team anyway. It’s only fitting that he managed to play just six minutes in a blowout loss for the East.