The Most Head-Scratching All-Star Selections In NBA History, Ranked - Page 2 of 42

23. Kenny Anderson (1994)

Anderson was great in college at Georgia Tech but failed to live up to the hype in his pro career. The guard with impressive handles played 14 years in the NBA while averaging only 12.6 PPG and 6.1 APG. While decent numbers, they’re not what you’d expect from a former second-overall pick.

His only All-Star appearance came in his third year in the league when he averaged just under 19 PPG and 10 APG. He got progressively worse thereafter until he retired.