22. Jameer Nelson (2009)

Nelson was a key piece for the 2009 Orlando Magic team that made it to the NBA Finals, but he wasn’t the talent many thought he’d be after winning the Player of the Year award during his last year at St. Joseph’s University.

Nelson was a dependable point guard, though he never averaged more than 16.7 PPG in any season in his career. After spending the first decade of his career in Orlando, he became more or less a journeyman thereafter, never being a difference-maker again.