Laura Benanti

Laura Benanti was no stranger to the silver screen when she joined the cast of Supergirl as Alura. Audiences believed she was a perfect fit for the role, though it would be short-lived. Her schedule was just too hectic to remain on the series.

She simply couldn’t get out of previous commitments in New York, which conflicted with her on-set schedule. After her departure, the role went to Erica Durance of Smallville, offering fans a small measure of comfort. One can only wonder what the show would’ve been like had she remained as part of the cast.