18. Zyrdunas Ilgauskas (2003, 2005)

Ilgauskas benefited more from the lack of big-man depth in the Eastern Conference during his prime. He was an All-Star twice, mostly because the East lacked any skilled centers. It could be argued that Ilgauskas was never a top-5 big at any point in his career.

Another Cavalier who likely stayed relevant longer thanks to LeBron James, Ilgauskas spent nearly his entire career in Cleveland. His only season away from the team in the NBA was his last one with the Miami Heat in 2010-2011.