Teenie Henrickson – Big Love

Tancy, also known as Teenie, probably didn’t fool many fans when the actress behind the role was switched out on Big Love. Both actresses had red hair, so at least that’s more of a similarity than a lot of these recasts.

Bella Thorne replaced Jolean Wejbe, who supposedly started to look too mature for the role. Either way, Thorne was told by the producers to make the character her own, and not to try and mimic Wejbe’s character.