Toby Cavenaugh – Pretty Little Liars

Potential spoilers ahead, but the character of Toby Cavenaugh in Pretty Little Liars has gone through a lot. First, he was seduced by his step-sister Jenna so she could blackmail him, but eventually, he became a cop and found love with somebody outside the family.

In the pilot episode, Toby was actually named Toby Marshall and was played by James Neate. Then, Keegan Allen took over the role as Toby Cavenaugh, while Neate went on to star in The Man in the High Castle.